Möbius Transformations and Steiner Circles
Explore fractional linear maps, cross ratios, circle symmetry, and the geometry of fixed points.
Learning goals
- Build and invert a Möbius map.
- Use three-point normalization and cross ratios.
- Interpret Steiner families and classify a nonidentity transformation.
A fractional linear transformation
Translations, scalings and inversion suggest a broader family of maps of the extended complex plane. A Möbius transformation combines these operations in a fractional linear formula. We will identify its exceptional input and inverse before studying the circles and relationships it preserves.
Möbius map
\[T(z)=\frac{az+b}{cz+d},\qquad ad-bc\ne0\]The determinant condition rules out constant maps. Multiplying all four coefficients by the same nonzero scalar leaves the map unchanged.
When \(c\ne0\), the pole \(-d/c\) maps to infinity and \(T(\infty)=a/c\). When \(c=0\), infinity is fixed.
Inverse and decomposition
Find the inverse and explain why every Möbius map is bijective on the extended plane.
Show worked solution
The inverse has the same nonzero determinant. Each formula extends over its pole and infinity, and the compositions are the identity there as well.
\[T(z)=\frac ac-\frac{ad-bc}{c^2}\frac1{z+d/c}\quad(c\ne0)\]This decomposition uses translations, a nonzero complex multiplication, and reciprocal inversion.
Generalized circles
Why include lines with circles?
In the extended complex plane, a generalized circle, or cline, is either a Euclidean circle or a Euclidean line together with the point at infinity.
The combined family is useful because Möbius maps preserve it even when an ordinary circle becomes a line. The classification therefore remains stable under these transformations.
A fractional linear map can send an ordinary circle through infinity, so a vocabulary containing only finite circles would miss part of the picture. We include lines as generalized circles. When following one through a map, check whether it meets the point sent to infinity; that helps explain why the image may look so different.
Cline
A cline is a circle, or a straight line together with infinity. Möbius transformations take clines to clines.
Translations and nonzero complex multiplications preserve this family. Reciprocal inversion does too, as can be checked by substituting into a circle or line equation. The decomposition therefore establishes the result for every Möbius transformation.
A circle becomes a line
Find the image of \(|z|=1\) under \(T(z)=i(1+z)/(1-z)\).
Show worked solution
Solve for \(z=(w-i)/(w+i)\). The unit-circle equation becomes \(|w-i|=|w+i|\), the perpendicular bisector of \(i\) and \(-i\): the real axis. The pole \(z=1\) supplies infinity.
Three points determine the map
The general formula has several coefficients, but multiplying all of them by the same nonzero number does not change the map. Rather than guess those coefficients, we can prescribe the images of three distinct points. Normalization makes the construction systematic.
\[N(z)=\frac{z-z_2}{z-z_3}\frac{z_1-z_3}{z_1-z_2}\]For three distinct points, this sends \(z_1,z_2,z_3\) to \(1,0,\infty\). If a point is infinity, use the corresponding limit. To map one triple to another, normalize the first and undo the normalization of the second.
Prescribe three point images
Find a map with \(T(1)=4\), \(T(0)=i\), \(T(\infty)=-1\).
Show worked solution
Set \(d=1\). Then \(b=i\) and \(a=-c\). The remaining condition gives \(-c+i=4c+4\), so \(c=(i-4)/5\). Multiplying coefficients by five yields:
\[T(z)=\frac{(4-i)z+5i}{(i-4)z+5}\]Its determinant is \(25+15i\ne0\). Direct substitution checks the three prescribed images.
Why uniqueness holds
Prove that two Möbius maps agreeing at three distinct points are the same.
Show worked solution
Compose the first with the inverse of the second. The resulting map fixes three distinct points. For a nonidentity fractional linear map, the fixed-point equation is a nonzero quadratic, with infinity counted when appropriate, and has at most two solutions. Thus the composite is identity.
Cross ratio as an invariant
Three point images can determine the map. What information, then, describes the position of a fourth point relative to them? The cross ratio gives us a quantity to compare before and after a transformation. Keep the ordering of the four points fixed: changing that order can change the value even though the same points appear.
Order matters
\[[z_0,z_1,z_2,z_3]=\frac{(z_0-z_2)(z_1-z_3)}{(z_0-z_3)(z_1-z_2)}\]Use distinct points and take limits for infinity. Permuting points can change the value.
Compute a cross ratio
Find \([2,1,0,\infty]\).
Show worked solution
As the last point tends to infinity, the ratio of the two factors involving it tends to one.
\[[2,1,0,\infty]=\frac{2-0}{1-0}=2\]Prove invariance
Explain why \([Tz_0,Tz_1,Tz_2,Tz_3]=[z_0,z_1,z_2,z_3]\).
Show worked solution
Normalize the last three source points to one, zero, infinity. Normalizing their images and then applying the original map does exactly the same thing to those three points. Uniqueness makes these two composites identical, so their values at the remaining point agree. Those values are the two cross ratios.
Four distinct points lie on one cline exactly when their cross ratio is real: normalization sends the cline through the last three points to the extended real line.
Symmetry in a circle
Reflection in a line is familiar. Circle symmetry asks us to replace that mirror with a circle and track how inside and outside correspond. Keep the fixed circle and the paired points distinct, and check what happens at the center and infinity when working on the extended plane.
\[z^*=a+\frac{R^2}{\bar z-\bar a}\]For a circle centered at a with radius R, a point and its reflection lie on the same radial ray and the product of their distances from the center is the squared radius. The center and infinity are paired.
Reflect a point and prove the rule
Reflect \(z=1+i\) in the unit circle, and show that reflection twice returns the original point.
Show worked solution
If \(u=z-a\), the reflected displacement is \(R^2/\bar u\). Conjugate that displacement and apply the rule again to obtain \(R^2/(R^2/u)=u\). Points of the circle are fixed because \(u\bar u=R^2\).
Two Steiner families
A fixed pair of points can organize many circles at once. One family passes through the pair; the other compares distances to them. Look at how the two families meet, because that relationship will help us interpret Möbius motion geometrically.
Choose distinct finite points \(p,q\), and set \(S(z)=(z-p)/(z-q)\). In the new coordinate, these become zero and infinity.
| Family | After normalization | Before normalization |
|---|---|---|
| First kind | Lines through the origin | Clines through both fixed points |
| Second kind | Concentric circles about the origin | \(|z-p|=k|z-q|,\quad k>0\) |
The families intersect orthogonally. Their normalized pictures are radial lines and circles; conformality carries the right angles back. The second family includes a line when the distance ratio is one.
Practice: equation of a family member
For \(p=0,q=1\), find \(|z|=2|z-1|\).
Show worked solution
This is an Apollonius circle, one member of the second Steiner family.
Fixed points organize the motion
What a fixed point tells us
A fixed point is a location sent to itself by a transformation.
Other points can still move around or relative to it. Sending fixed points to convenient coordinates helps simplify a Möbius map and reveal the type of motion it represents.
A formula can hide the character of a transformation. Find its fixed points, move them to convenient positions, and the formula becomes much simpler. We can then distinguish rotation-like, translation-like, and mixed behavior by the remaining multiplier.
For two fixed points, normalization turns a nonidentity map into multiplication by a nonzero multiplier.
\[S(Tz)=\lambda S(z)\]| Multiplier | Type | Normalized motion |
|---|---|---|
| \(|\lambda|=1,\ \lambda\ne1\) | Elliptic | Rotation |
| \(\lambda>0,\ \lambda\ne1\) | Hyperbolic | Positive dilation |
| \(|\lambda|\ne1,\ \arg\lambda\ne0\) | Loxodromic | Dilation and rotation |
Classify a fractional linear map
Classify \(T(z)=-z/(2z-3)\).
Show worked solution
The fixed-point equation gives \(2z^2-2z=0\), so the fixed points are zero and one. For \(S(z)=z/(z-1)\):
\[S(Tz)=\frac{-z/(2z-3)}{-z/(2z-3)-1}=\frac13\frac z{z-1}\]The multiplier is a positive real number different from one, so the transformation is hyperbolic.
Use the normal form to predict repeated motion
A fixed point p is attracting if sufficiently nearby points approach p under repeated applications; it is repelling if it is attracting for the inverse. In a coordinate \(S(z)=(z-p)/(z-q)\) with two distinct finite fixed points, \(S(Tz)=\lambda S(z)\) gives \(S(T^nz)=\lambda^nS(z)\). If \(|\lambda|<1\), every point except q approaches p on the sphere. If \(|\lambda|>1\), every point except p approaches q. The excluded point is itself fixed, so it cannot approach the other.
Recover an orbit in the original plane
Let \(S(z)=z/(z-1)\) and \(S(Tz)=S(z)/3\). Start at \(z=2\). Find the nth iterate, identify any iterate at infinity, and find the limit.
Show worked solution
The starting coordinate is \(S(2)=2\), so \(S(T^n2)=2/3^n\). Solving \(w=z/(z-1)\) gives \(z=w/(w-1)\), hence \(T^n2=2/(2-3^n)\). For integer n≥0 the denominator is never zero. The sequence tends to zero, the attracting fixed point. The other fixed point one stays at one. A large normalized coordinate and a large original coordinate are not the same statement.
For a unit-modulus multiplier, shrinking is absent. A root of unity gives periodic motion; other unit multipliers need not return exactly. Classification describes the normalized motion, so translate conclusions back through S.
One fixed point: the degenerate case
Our earlier normalization used two distinct fixed points. If those points merge, that construction no longer applies as written. Move the single fixed point to infinity and examine the remaining map. This explains why the degenerate case needs its own description rather than a substitution into a formula with coincident points.
A nonidentity map with one fixed point is parabolic. Send its fixed point to infinity. A Möbius map fixing infinity is affine, and having no finite fixed point forces it to be \(w\mapsto w+\beta\) with \(\beta\ne0\).
\[\frac1{Tz-p}=\frac1{z-p}+\beta\]Parallel lines in the normalized picture return to clines tangent at the fixed point. These are degenerate Steiner families.
A parabolic example
Show that \(T(z)=z/(z+1)\) has one fixed point and find its normalized translation.
Show worked solution
Infinity maps to one, so it is not fixed. The sole fixed point is zero.
\[\frac1{Tz}=\frac1z+1\]Always exclude identity before using the one-or-two-fixed-points classification. Identity fixes every point.
Möbius Geometry: discussion A–F
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Question A
Verify the decomposition of \(T(z)=(az+b)/(cz+d)\) when \(c\ne0\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use the denominator \(c(cz+d)\).
Put \(\Delta=ad-bc\ne0\). Bringing the proposed expression to a common denominator gives \[\frac ac-\frac{\Delta}{c^2}\frac1{z+d/c}=\frac{a(cz+d)-(ad-bc)}{c(cz+d)}=\frac{az+b}{cz+d}.\] The equality extends to the pole and infinity as an equality of maps of the Riemann sphere.
Question B
Choose coefficients that represent a rotation, translation, homothety and inversion.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Start with denominator \(1\) for the first three maps.
The coefficient quadruples \((a,b,c,d)\) may be \((e^{i\theta},0,0,1)\) for rotation; \((1,v,0,1)\) for translation; \((k,0,0,1)\) for homothety, \(k>0\); and \((0,1,1,0)\) for the book's inversion \(1/z\). Their determinants are respectively \(e^{i\theta},1,k,-1\), all nonzero.
Question C
Check that \(N(z)=\frac{z-z_2}{z-z_3}\frac{z_1-z_3}{z_1-z_2}\) maps three distinct finite points \(z_1,z_2,z_3\) to \(1,0,\infty\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Check the numerator and denominator separately at each point.
At \(z_1\) the two nonzero ratios cancel to \(1\). At \(z_2\) the numerator is zero and denominator nonzero. At \(z_3\) the denominator is zero but the numerator is nonzero, so the sphere value is \(\infty\). If an input is infinity, take the corresponding limit.
Question D
Prove that any two figures consisting of three distinct points are Möbius-congruent.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Choose an ordering of each set.
Order the points as \((z_1,z_2,z_3)\) and \((w_1,w_2,w_3)\). The fundamental theorem provides a Möbius map sending each \(z_j\) to \(w_j\). It therefore maps the first three-point set onto the second. Different orderings can give different maps, but existence is all congruence requires.
Question E
What counterpart of three-point transitivity holds for translations?
Show worked solution
Approach.
A translation preserves a displacement vector.
Any chosen point \(z\) can be sent to any chosen point \(w\) by the unique translation \(T(u)=u+w-z\). Two ordered pairs are translation-congruent precisely when \(z_2-z_1=w_2-w_1\). Thus arbitrary one-point figures, but not arbitrary two-point figures, are congruent.
Question F
When \(a\bar c-c\bar a=0\), verify that the reality equation reduces to \(\operatorname{Im}(\alpha z+\beta)=0\), where \(\alpha=a\bar d-c\bar b\) and \(\beta=b\bar d\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Recognize each term as a number minus its conjugate.
The remaining equation is \(\alpha z-\bar\alpha\bar z+\beta-\bar\beta=0\). Since \(u-\bar u=2i\operatorname{Im}u\), this is exactly \(2i\operatorname{Im}(\alpha z+\beta)=0\). Also \(\alpha\ne0\). If \(c=0\), the determinant condition gives \(a,d\ne0\), hence \(\alpha=a\bar d\ne0\). If \(c\ne0\), the leading-coefficient condition says \(a/c=k\) is real. Were \(\alpha=0\), then \(k\bar d=\bar b\), so \(b=kd\) and \(ad-bc=0\), a contradiction. Thus this really is a line.
Möbius Geometry: discussion G
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Question G
Are all clines congruent in Möbius geometry?
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use three points and preservation of clines.
Yes. Choose three distinct points on each cline. The unique Möbius map matching those triples maps the first cline to a cline through the second triple. A triple of distinct sphere points determines a unique cline, so its image is the second cline.
Möbius Geometry: exercises 1–6
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 1
Verify that the cross ratio \(N(z)=[z,z_1,z_2,z_3]\) is a Möbius map sending \(z_1,z_2,z_3\) to \(1,0,\infty\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Write the cross ratio in linear-fractional form.
For finite distinct reference points set \(K=(z_1-z_3)/(z_1-z_2)\ne0\). Then \(N(z)=(Kz-Kz_2)/(z-z_3)\) has determinant \(K(z_2-z_3)\ne0\). Substitution gives \(N(z_1)=1\), \(N(z_2)=0\) and \(N(z_3)=\infty\). Limits handle a reference point at infinity and still give a nonzero-determinant map.
Exercise 2
Find \([z_0,\infty,z_2,z_3]\), \([z_0,z_1,\infty,z_3]\) and \([z_0,z_1,z_2,\infty]\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
The ratio \((u-a)/(u-b)\) tends to \(1\) as \(u\to\infty\).
Divide the factors involving the variable tending to infinity by that variable. The limits are, respectively, \[\frac{z_0-z_2}{z_0-z_3},\qquad\frac{z_1-z_3}{z_0-z_3},\qquad\frac{z_0-z_2}{z_1-z_2}.\] These formulas assume the other three points are finite and distinct; the cross ratio is interpreted on the sphere at a remaining pole.
Exercise 3
Find Möbius maps (a) \(1\mapsto4,0\mapsto i,\infty\mapsto-1\); (b) \(0\mapsto0,i\mapsto1,-i\mapsto2\); (c) \(1\mapsto2,2\mapsto3,3\mapsto1\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Normalize one coefficient, then impose the three prescribed values.
(a) Set \(d=1\), so \(b=i\) and \(a=-c\). The condition at \(1\) gives \(-c+i=4c+4\), hence \(c=(i-4)/5\). Thus \(T(z)=((4-i)z+5i)/((i-4)z+5)\).
(b) Set \(b=0,d=1\). The two remaining conditions give \(ai=ci+1\) and \(-ai=2(-ci+1)\); hence \(c=-3i,a=-4i\). Thus \(T(z)=-4iz/(1-3iz)\).
(c) With \(d=1\), equations \(a+b=2c+2\), \(2a+b=6c+3\), \(3a+b=3c+1\) give \(c=-3/7,a=-5/7,b=13/7\). Thus \(T(z)=(13-5z)/(7-3z)\). Each displayed map has nonzero determinant, and direct substitution checks all three values. Uniqueness follows from the fundamental theorem.
Exercise 4
Find a Möbius map taking the unit circle to the line \(x+y=1\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
First map the circle to the real axis, then rotate and translate.
The Cayley map \(u=i(1+z)/(1-z)\) takes the unit circle to the extended real axis: for \(|z|=1\), conjugating \(u\) leaves it unchanged. Then \(w=1+(1-i)u\) has real part \(1+u\) and imaginary part \(-u\) when \(u\) is real, so \(x+y=1\). Consequently \[T(z)=1+(1+i)\frac{1+z}{1-z}\] works, with \(z=1\) mapped to the line's point at infinity.
Exercise 5
Find the map representing a counterclockwise rotation through \(90^\circ\) about \(1\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Rotate \(z-1\), not \(z\).
Translate the center to zero, multiply by \(i\), and translate back: \(T(z)=1+i(z-1)=iz+1-i\). It fixes \(1\), preserves distances and multiplies every displacement from \(1\) by \(i\).
Exercise 6
Find all fixed points of (a) \(2z/(3z-1)\), (b) \((3z-2)/(2z-1)\), (c) \(-2/(z+1)\), (d) \(-iz/((1-i)z-1)\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use \(cz^2+(d-a)z-b=0\), then check infinity.
Each denominator has nonzero coefficient of \(z\), so infinity is not fixed. Solve after cross multiplication and check that no root is a pole.
(a) \(3z^2-3z=0\), so \(z=0,1\). (b) \(2z^2-4z+2=0\), so the sole fixed point is \(z=1\). (c) \(z^2+z+2=0\), giving \(z=(-1\pm i\sqrt7)/2\). (d) \((1-i)z^2+(i-1)z=0\), so \(z=0,1\).
Möbius Geometry: exercises 7–12
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 7
Prove the formulas for \(T(\infty)\) and the pole of a Möbius map. What happens when \(c=0\)?
Show worked solution
Approach.
The determinant condition prevents numerator and denominator from vanishing together.
For \(c\ne0\), divide numerator and denominator by \(z\): \(T(\infty)=a/c\). At \(z=-d/c\), the numerator equals \((bc-ad)/c\ne0\), so \(T(-d/c)=\infty\). If \(c=0\), then \(a,d\ne0\), and \(T(z)=(a/d)z+b/d\) has no finite pole and fixes infinity.
Exercise 8
Find all Möbius maps (a) whose two fixed points are \(1,-1\); (b) whose sole fixed point is \(-1\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Move the fixed points to \(0,\infty\), or move the single fixed point to infinity.
(a) Conjugate by \(S(z)=(z-1)/(z+1)\). A map fixing \(0,\infty\) is \(w\mapsto\lambda w\), where \(\lambda\ne0\). Solving \(S(Tz)=\lambda S(z)\) gives \[T(z)=\frac{(1+\lambda)z+1-\lambda}{(1-\lambda)z+1+\lambda},\quad\lambda\ne0,1.\] Exclude \(\lambda=1\) because the identity has every point fixed.
(b) Conjugate by \(S(z)=1/(z+1)\). A nonidentity map with sole fixed point infinity is \(w\mapsto w+\beta\), \(\beta\ne0\). Hence \(T(z)=-1+(z+1)/(1+\beta(z+1))\). These and only these maps have the requested fixed-point sets.
Exercise 9
Prove that determinants multiply under composition of Möbius maps.
Clarifies the book’s determinant notation, which depends on the representative matrix.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use the matrix of the composition.
Represent \(T,S\) by matrices \(A=\begin{pmatrix}a&b\\c&d\end{pmatrix}\) and \(B=\begin{pmatrix}e&f\\g&h\end{pmatrix}\). Substitution represents \(T\circ S\) by \(AB\). Expansion gives \(\det(AB)=(ad-bc)(eh-fg)=\det A\det B\). This statement concerns the chosen coefficient matrices: a Möbius map itself has no uniquely specified determinant, since multiplying all coefficients by \(k\ne0\) multiplies the determinant by \(k^2\).
Exercise 10
Explain why allowing determinant zero makes a linear-fractional expression constant and why constants cannot belong to a transformation group.
Adds the necessary nonzero-denominator-row hypothesis.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Linearly dependent coefficient rows produce a constant ratio.
If the denominator row \((c,d)\) is nonzero and \(ad-bc=0\), then \((a,b)=k(c,d)\) for some \(k\), so the quotient equals \(k\) wherever defined. Any common zero is a removable defect, not a bijective sphere map. If \((c,d)=(0,0)\) the quotient is not a valid finite-valued formula at all; projectively a nonzero numerator would give the constant infinity map away from its zero. A constant map on the sphere is not injective and has no inverse, so cannot be a transformation.
Exercise 11
Prove that a Möbius map whose only fixed point is infinity is a translation.
Show worked solution
Approach.
An affine map with slope other than \(1\) has a finite fixed point.
Fixing infinity forces \(c=0\), so \(T(z)=\alpha z+\beta\), \(\alpha\ne0\). If \(\alpha\ne1\), then \(\beta/(1-\alpha)\) is a finite fixed point, contradiction. Thus \(\alpha=1\). Also \(\beta\ne0\), since otherwise every point is fixed. Hence it is a nonzero translation.
Exercise 12
Show every Möbius map has a determinant-one representation. Is it unique?
Show worked solution
Approach.
Scaling all coefficients does not change the map.
Choose a square root \(s\) of \(\Delta=ad-bc\ne0\). Divide all four coefficients by \(s\). The map is unchanged and the new determinant is \(\Delta/s^2=1\). The two choices \(s,-s\) give opposite matrices. Any two matrices for the same Möbius map differ by a nonzero scalar; determinant one forces that scalar's square to be \(1\). Therefore there are exactly two such matrices, \(A\) and \(-A\).
Möbius Geometry: exercises 13–18
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 13
Prove that every Möbius transformation is conformal on the sphere.
Show worked solution
Approach.
At a pole, differentiate the reciprocal target coordinate.
At any finite nonpole, \(T'(z)=(ad-bc)/(cz+d)^2\ne0\). Its differential is multiplication by a nonzero complex number, which rotates and scales all tangent vectors equally and preserves oriented angles. At a pole use the target coordinate \(v=1/T(z)\); its derivative there is nonzero. At infinity use the source coordinate \(u=1/z\), and also the reciprocal target coordinate if needed. The same nonzero-determinant calculation proves a nonzero derivative in these charts. Thus conformality holds at every sphere point.
Exercise 14
State and prove an analogue of the Möbius fundamental theorem for the book's orientation-preserving Euclidean group.
Show worked solution
Approach.
The quotient of the displacement vectors must have modulus \(1\).
Two ordered pairs of distinct points \((p,q)\) and \((r,s)\) can be matched by exactly one orientation-preserving Euclidean motion if and only if \(|q-p|=|s-r|\). Necessity follows from distance invariance. For sufficiency set \(\alpha=(s-r)/(q-p)\); equality of distances gives \(|\alpha|=1\). The map \(T(z)=r+\alpha(z-p)\) sends the pairs correctly. Any such motion must have this multiplier and translation, proving uniqueness. Arbitrary pairs with unequal separation cannot be matched.
Exercise 15
State and prove fundamental theorems for translational geometry and for rotations about the origin.
Show worked solution
Approach.
A translation is determined by its displacement; a rotation preserves radius.
Translations act uniquely transitively on individual points: \(T(z)=z+w-p\) is the unique translation sending \(p\) to \(w\). For rotations about the origin, two nonzero points \(p,w\) can be matched if and only if \(|p|=|w|\); then the unique rotation is \(T(z)=(w/p)z\). Zero can only map to zero, and every rotation does that, so uniqueness fails there.
Exercise 16
Prove that all clines are Möbius-congruent.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use the three-point theorem, not just a sketch.
Choose three distinct points on each cline. A Möbius map carries the first triple to the second. It maps clines to clines, and a cline through a prescribed triple of distinct sphere points is unique. Thus the entire first cline maps to the second.
Exercise 17
Determine which configurations in Figure 5.3 are Möbius-congruent: (a) a circle and two perpendicular lines, one disjoint from the circle and one its diameter line; (b) two circles and their common tangent at their shared tangency; (c) three pairwise tangent circles at three different points; (d) two externally tangent circles and their common external tangent; (e) three parallel lines; (f) two concentric circles and a diameter line.
Schematic figure classification; exact metric congruence cannot be inferred from an unscaled drawing alone.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Send a common tangency point to infinity and count preserved intersections.
The indicated incidence classes are \((a,f)\), \((b,e)\) and \((c,d)\). In (a), send the unique symmetric limiting pair of the two disjoint clines to \(0,\infty\). They become concentric circles, while their common perpendicular becomes a line through zero, giving (f). In (b), send the common tangency to infinity: all three clines become parallel lines, giving (e). In (c), send the tangency of the outer circle and one inner circle to infinity. Those two become parallel lines and the third becomes a circle tangent to both; the same construction on (d), using a circle–line tangency, gives this canonical configuration.
The three classes differ by preserved incidence: the first has transverse intersections; the second has one common tangency of all three clines; the third has three distinct pairwise tangencies. A qualification is important: arbitrary drawings within a class can carry numerical invariants. For example three parallel lines have a spacing ratio (up to permutation) preserved by affine maps fixing infinity. The scan is a schematic congruence puzzle, not metric data sufficient to certify every arbitrary realization.
Exercise 18
Find the points symmetric in the unit circle to \(1,1/2,i,i/2,1+i,(1+i)/2\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Divide each point by its squared modulus.
Use \(z^*=1/\bar z=z/|z|^2\). In the stated order the answers are \(1,2,i,2i,(1+i)/2,1+i\). Each pair lies on the same ray and its moduli multiply to \(1\); points on the unit circle are fixed.
Möbius Geometry: exercises 19–24
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 19
For the circle of center \(i\) and radius \(2\), find the symmetric points to \(0,1,2,\sqrt3,3\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Rationalize \(4/(x+i)\).
For real \(x\), the formula becomes \(z^*=i+4/(x+i)=4x/(x^2+1)+i(1-4/(x^2+1))\). Substituting gives, in order, \(-3i\), \(2-i\), \(8/5+i/5\), \(\sqrt3\), and \(6/5+3i/5\). The fixed value \(\sqrt3\) lies on the circle since \(|\sqrt3-i|=2\).
Exercise 20
Prove the tangent construction of a circle-symmetric point: for an interior point \(z\ne a\), the chord perpendicular to \(az\) through \(z\) meets the circle at \(B,D\); their tangents meet at \(z^*\). Explain the exterior and exceptional cases.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Write the two tangent equations after placing the center at zero.
Rotate and translate so the center is \(0\), the point is \(x\in(0,R)\) and the chord is vertical. Then \(B=(x,\sqrt{R^2-x^2})\) and \(D=(x,-\sqrt{R^2-x^2})\). The tangent equations are \(xX\pm\sqrt{R^2-x^2}Y=R^2\). Their intersection is \((R^2/x,0)\), so the radial distances multiply to \(R^2\), exactly the symmetry formula. Reversing the construction proves the exterior case. At the center the tangents are parallel and meet at infinity; a point on the circle is its own symmetric point, handled as a limit.
Exercise 21
Prove uniqueness of the point symmetric to a given point with respect to a circle.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Invert the normalizing Möbius map.
Choose three distinct reference points on the circle and let \(N\) be their cross-ratio normalizer. The defining equation is \(N(z^*)=\overline{N(z)}\). Since \(N\) is a bijection of the sphere, exactly one solution exists: \(z^*=N^{-1}(\overline{N(z)})\). This includes the center and infinity. For a circle of center \(a\) and radius \(R\), the explicit formula is \(a+R^2/(\bar z-\bar a)\), with \(a\leftrightarrow\infty\).
Exercise 22
Show symmetry with respect to a straight line is ordinary mirror reflection.
Show worked solution
Approach.
First treat the real axis.
For the real axis take real reference points; their normalizer has real coefficients, so \(N(\bar z)=\overline{N(z)}\). Uniqueness therefore gives \(z^*=\bar z\). For a general line choose a Euclidean motion \(U\) mapping it to the real axis. Symmetry is Möbius-invariant, hence its reflection is \(U^{-1}(\overline{U(z)})\), exactly the Euclidean mirror construction.
Exercise 23
Compare unit-circle symmetry and the book's inversion. What complex operation is symmetry across the real axis?
Show worked solution
Approach.
Evaluate both maps at \(i\).
Unit-circle symmetry is \(J(z)=1/\bar z\); the book's inversion is \(I(z)=1/z\). They differ, for example \(J(i)=i\) while \(I(i)=-i\). They are related by \(I=K\circ J=J\circ K\), where \(K(z)=\bar z\) is reflection in the real axis. \(I\) preserves orientation and \(J\) reverses it.
Exercise 24
Let \(z,z^*\) be distinct reflections in a line \(C\). Prove that a circle through \(z\) is orthogonal to \(C\) if and only if it also passes through \(z^*\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Equidistance from conjugate points forces the center onto the real axis.
Move \(C\) to the real axis. Write \(z=x+iy\) with \(y\ne0\), so \(z^*=x-iy\). A circle orthogonal to the real axis has center on that axis: at an intersection its radius must be horizontal, since its tangent is vertical. It is then invariant under conjugation and contains both points. Conversely, if its center is \(u+iv\), equality of its squared distances from \(x+iy\) and \(x-iy\) gives \(4vy=0\), hence \(v=0\). Its radius exceeds \(|v|=0\), so it crosses the real axis orthogonally. Undo the motion.
Möbius Geometry: exercises 25
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 25
Extend the preceding result to arbitrary clines \(C,C'\) and distinct points \(z,z^*\) symmetric with respect to \(C\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Normalize the reflecting cline and include the straight-line case.
Choose a Möbius map taking \(C\) to the extended real axis and avoiding infinity at the two points. Symmetry, incidences and angles are preserved. For a circle the claim is Exercise 24. A line through conjugate nonreal points is vertical and thus perpendicular to the real axis; conversely a perpendicular line through one conjugate contains the other. These cover all image clines. Transforming back proves both directions, including configurations whose original points involve infinity.
Steiner Circles: discussion A–B
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Question A
Which points are exceptions to uniqueness of the Steiner cline of the first kind through a point? What happens for the second kind?
Show worked solution
Approach.
Move \(p,q\) to \(0,\infty\).
Every first-kind cline passes through both distinguished points \(p,q\), so at either of these there are infinitely many choices. At every other point \(z\), the triple \(p,q,z\) determines exactly one cline. For the second kind, neither \(p\) nor \(q\) belongs to any member: in the coordinate \(w=(z-p)/(z-q)\) those points are \(0,\infty\), whereas the members are \(|w|=k\) with \(0<k<\infty\). Every other point lies on exactly one such level set, namely \(k=|w|\).
Question B
Describe a sketch of loxodromic motion around its two fixed points.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Combine radial dilation and angular rotation in the normalized plane.
In normalized coordinates write \(w(t)=e^{t(\log k+i\theta)}w_0\), where \(k>0\), \(k\ne1\), and \(\theta\not\equiv0\pmod{2\pi}\). Radius changes by \(k^t\) while argument changes by \(t\theta\), so this is a logarithmic spiral. Apply \(S^{-1}\), where \(S(z)=(z-p)/(z-q)\), to obtain \(z(t)=(q w(t)-p)/(w(t)-1)\). Draw first-kind and second-kind Steiner clines as the coordinate grid and the orbit crossing both families. For \(k<1\) forward motion tends to \(p\); for \(k>1\) it tends to \(q\). The discrete orbit consists of the integer-time points.
Steiner Circles: exercises 1–6
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 1
Prove that the multiplier in \(\frac{Tz-p}{Tz-q}=\lambda\frac{z-p}{z-q}\) is \([Tz,z,p,q]\).
Corrects the source phrase “any complex number”: the fixed points are excluded.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Solve the normal-form equation for \(\lambda\).
For \(z\ne p,q\), divide by \((z-p)/(z-q)\) to obtain \[\lambda=\frac{Tz-p}{Tz-q}\frac{z-q}{z-p}=[Tz,z,p,q].\] Sphere limits handle an infinite entry. The fixed points themselves must be excluded from this evaluation: the displayed quotient otherwise contains an indeterminate cancellation. The constant multiplier is determined by any nonfixed point.
Exercise 2
For a parabolic map with finite fixed point \(p\) and normal form \(1/(Tz-p)=1/(z-p)+\beta\), let \(T(z_0)=\infty\). Prove \(\beta=-1/(z_0-p)=1/(T(\infty)-p)\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Evaluate at the pole and at infinity.
Substitute \(z=z_0\): the left side is zero, so \(\beta=-1/(z_0-p)\). Substitute \(z=\infty\): the term \(1/(z-p)\) is zero, so \(\beta=1/(T(\infty)-p)\). Here \(\beta\ne0\) because the map is not the identity; its pole is finite and distinct from \(p\).
Exercise 3
Find fixed points, normal forms and motion types for (a) \(z/(2z-1)\), (b) \((3z-4)/(z-1)\), (c) \(z/(2-z)\), (d) \(-z/((1+i)z-i)\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Solve \(Tz=z\) before choosing the normalizing map.
(a) The fixed equation is \(2z(z-1)=0\). With \(p=0,q=1\), \(S(z)=z/(z-1)\) gives \(S(Tz)=-S(z)\), so \(\lambda=-1\): an elliptic half-turn. Orbits lie on second-kind Steiner clines.
(b) The fixed equation is \((z-2)^2=0\). Direct simplification gives \(1/(Tz-2)=1/(z-2)+1\). Thus \(p=2\), \(\beta=1\), a parabolic map. In the \(1/(z-2)\) plane motion is to the right along horizontal lines; pull these back to circles tangent at \(2\).
(c) The fixed points are \(0,1\). For \(S(z)=z/(z-1)\), \(S(Tz)=\tfrac12S(z)\). This is hyperbolic; forward nonfixed orbits tend to \(0\) along first-kind clines.
(d) The fixed equation gives \(0,i\). For \(S(z)=z/(z-i)\), \(S(Tz)=-iS(z)\). This is an elliptic quarter-turn, with orbits on the second-kind family for \(0,i\). These normal forms provide the coordinate grids for the sketches.
Exercise 4
Find the normal form of \(T(z)=e^{i\theta}z+b\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Separate rotations from translations before solving for the fixed point.
Put \(\alpha=e^{i\theta}\). If \(\alpha\ne1\), the finite fixed point is \(p=b/(1-\alpha)\), the other is infinity, and \(Tz-p=\alpha(z-p)\) is its normal form. If \(\alpha=1,b\ne0\), the map is already the parabolic normal form \(Tz=z+b\) with fixed point infinity. If \(\alpha=1,b=0\), it is the identity and has no distinguished fixed-point normal form.
Exercise 5
When is \(e^{i\theta}z+b\) elliptic, hyperbolic, parabolic or loxodromic?
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use the normal forms from Exercise 4.
If \(e^{i\theta}\ne1\), its multiplier has modulus \(1\) and it is elliptic. If \(e^{i\theta}=1\) and \(b\ne0\), it is parabolic. If both \(e^{i\theta}=1\) and \(b=0\), it is the identity. A Euclidean motion of this orientation-preserving form is never nonidentity hyperbolic or loxodromic: those types require a multiplier with modulus different from \(1\).
Exercise 6
Classify inversion \(T(z)=1/z\) and find its normal form.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Solve \(z^2=1\) and normalize those points.
Its fixed points are \(1,-1\). For \(S(z)=(z-1)/(z+1)\), direct substitution gives \(S(1/z)=-S(z)\). Thus \(\lambda=-1\), so inversion is elliptic, a half-turn in normalized coordinates. This is the book's analytic inversion, not the orientation-reversing circle reflection \(1/\bar z\).
Steiner Circles: exercises 7–12
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 7
Find formulas for (a) an elliptic map fixing \(i,-i\) with \(T(\infty)=0\); (b) a parabolic map fixing \(1+i\) with \(T(\infty)=100\); (c) a hyperbolic map fixing \(5,10\) with \(T(\infty)=20\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
The image of infinity determines the remaining normal-form parameter.
(a) Set \(S(z)=(z-i)/(z+i)\). Since \(S(\infty)=1\) and \(S(0)=-1\), the multiplier is \(-1\). Solving gives \(T(z)=-1/z\).
(b) Put \(p=1+i\) and \(A=100-p=99-i\). The parabolic parameter is \(\beta=1/A\), giving \(T(z)=p+A(z-p)/(z-p+A)\). Expanding if desired gives \(T(z)=(100z-p^2)/(z+100-2p)\); it fixes only \(p\) and has the prescribed value at infinity.
(c) Set \(S(z)=(z-5)/(z-10)\). The multiplier is \(S(20)=3/2\). Solving \(S(Tz)=\tfrac32S(z)\) gives \(T(z)=(20z-50)/(z+5)\). Its determinant is \(150\ne0\), and it fixes \(5,10\).
Exercise 8
Describe \(\lim_{n\to\infty}T^n(z)\) for a hyperbolic or loxodromic map and identify the exception.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Study multiplication by \(\lambda^n\) first.
Write \(S(T^n z)=\lambda^nS(z)\), with \(S(p)=0,S(q)=\infty\). If \(|\lambda|<1\), the limit is \(p\) for every \(z\ne q\); the exceptional point \(q\) stays fixed. If \(|\lambda|>1\), the limit is \(q\) for every \(z\ne p\); \(p\) stays fixed. Limits are in the sphere, so a finite orbit can pass through infinity without invalidating the conclusion.
Exercise 9
Prove that a nonidentity Möbius involution is elliptic and determine its multiplier.
Adds the necessary nonidentity hypothesis.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Square the normal form.
A parabolic map is conjugate to \(w\mapsto w+\beta\) with \(\beta\ne0\); its square translates by \(2\beta\ne0\), so cannot be the identity. Thus a nonidentity involution has two fixed points and is conjugate to \(w\mapsto\lambda w\). Its square is the identity exactly when \(\lambda^2=1\). Since \(\lambda\ne1\), we have \(\lambda=-1\), an elliptic half-turn. The identity also satisfies \(T^2=I\) but is excluded from the asserted classification.
Exercise 10
If \(T=S^{-1}RS\), prove \(z\) is fixed by \(T\) if and only if \(Sz\) is fixed by \(R\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Apply \(S\) to the fixed-point equation.
Apply the bijection \(S\) to \(Tz=z\): this is equivalent to \(STz=Sz\). Because \(ST=RS\), it is equivalent to \(R(Sz)=Sz\). Every implication is reversible, proving both directions, including sphere points at infinity.
Exercise 11
Show a Möbius map taking \(z_1,z_2\) to \(w_1,w_2\) maps the first-kind Steiner family to the first-kind family for \(w_1,w_2\).
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use preservation of clines and incidence.
Each member is a cline through both \(z_1,z_2\). Its image is a cline through \(w_1,w_2\), hence belongs to the target family. Applying the same argument to the inverse map shows every member of the target family arises, so the mapping is onto the family.
Exercise 12
Prove that the clines perpendicular to every first-kind Steiner cline for distinct \(p,q\) are exactly the second-kind Steiner clines.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Normalize the pair so the first family consists of radial lines.
Send \(p,q\) to \(0,\infty\). The first family becomes all lines through zero. A circle perpendicular to a line has its center on that line. A circle perpendicular to every radial line must therefore have center zero; every circle centered at zero has the required perpendicularity. A straight line cannot be perpendicular to every radial direction, so gives no extra member. Pulling these circles back gives precisely the second-kind family.
Steiner Circles: exercises 13–16
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 13
Show Möbius maps carry second-kind Steiner families to the corresponding second-kind families of the image points.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Use the orthogonality characterization.
By Exercise 12 a second-kind member is characterized as a cline perpendicular to every first-kind member. Möbius maps preserve clines, angles and the first-kind family (Exercise 11), so its image has that same characterization for the image pair. The inverse gives surjectivity. This proof avoids assuming Euclidean distance ratios themselves are Möbius invariants.
Exercise 14
Prove two disjoint clines have a unique unordered pair of distinct points symmetric with respect to both.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Normalize one cline to a line and solve the two symmetry equations.
Move one cline to the real axis. The other cannot be a line, since all extended lines share infinity, so it is a circle with center \(a+ib\) and radius \(R\), where \(b^2>R^2\). A pair symmetric in the real axis has form \(z,\bar z\). Symmetry in the circle requires \[\bar z=a+ib+\frac{R^2}{\bar z-a+ib},\qquad(\bar z-a)^2=R^2-b^2.\] Thus the pair is exactly \(a\pm i\sqrt{b^2-R^2}\). These points are distinct and satisfy both symmetry formulas, proving existence and uniqueness. Transform back using invariance of symmetry.
Exercise 15
Describe all clines perpendicular to two distinct clines when they (a) intersect twice, (b) are tangent, (c) are disjoint.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Normalize each incidence type separately.
(a) Send the two intersections to \(0,\infty\). The clines become distinct lines through zero. Common perpendicular clines are exactly circles centered at zero: a circle's center must lie on both lines, and no line is perpendicular to both. Pulling back yields the second-kind Steiner family for the intersections.
(b) Send their tangency point to infinity. They become distinct parallel lines. No circle can have its center on both lines, while every line perpendicular to them is a common perpendicular. Pull back this parallel family: it is a degenerate Steiner family of clines through the common tangency, mutually tangent there.
(c) Use Exercise 14 to send their common symmetric pair to \(0,\infty\). Each original cline is perpendicular to every cline through that symmetric pair, so the images are concentric circles. Common perpendiculars are exactly radial lines: a circle perpendicular to circles of radii \(r\ne R\) would require simultaneously \(|c|^2=\rho^2+r^2=\rho^2+R^2\), impossible. Pulling back yields the first-kind family through the common symmetric pair.
Exercise 16
Given two disjoint clines and a third meeting both, prove there is exactly one cline perpendicular to all three.
Show worked solution
Approach.
Make the first two circles concentric.
Normalize the first two to concentric circles with distinct radii. By Exercise 15 their common perpendiculars are radial lines. If the third is a circle with center \(c\), then \(c\ne0\) (a concentric circle cannot meet either of the first circles), and exactly one radial line passes through \(c\); that line is perpendicular to the third circle. If the third is a straight line, exactly one radial line is perpendicular to it. In both cases this line is unique. Undo the normalization.
References and further study
Primary source: Michael Henle, Modern Geometries: Non-Euclidean, Projective, and Discrete, 2nd edition, Prentice Hall, 2001, pp. 55–77. ISBN 9780130323132. The supplied chapter scans determine the discussion sequence and source questions. Solutions are worked explanations; qualifications are noted where needed.
Book bibliographic record. Supplementary course notes provide supporting examples and model conventions.
Continue exploring
Synthesis and proof challenges
Normalization reduces a complicated fractional expression to a familiar motion, but a complete argument must still include exceptional points. These tasks connect algebraic iteration, fixed points and the extended plane.
Multi-step · Iterate a parabolic map
For \(T(z)=z/(z+1)\), find \(T^n(z)\) for every positive integer n. State the pole, the image of infinity and the fixed point of the iterate.
Hint
Use the coordinate w=1/z, where each application adds one.
Show worked solution
For generic finite z, \(1/T(z)=1/z+1\), hence \(1/T^n(z)=1/z+n\), giving \(T^n(z)=z/(nz+1)\). The same identity follows by induction as an equality of Möbius maps, so it remains valid even if an intermediate iterate is infinity. Its pole is \(-1/n\), infinity maps to \(1/n\), and solving \(z=z/(nz+1)\) gives \(nz^2=0\). Thus zero is its unique fixed point; infinity is not fixed.
Advanced / Honors · Three fixed points force identity
Prove that a Möbius transformation fixing three distinct points of the extended plane is identity, treating infinity explicitly.
Hint
Separate whether infinity is among the fixed points.
Show worked solution
Write \(T(z)=(az+b)/(cz+d)\) with nonzero determinant. If infinity is fixed, c=0, so \(T(z)=Az+B\) with A nonzero. Fixing two distinct finite points gives \((A-1)u+B=(A-1)v+B=0\); subtraction yields A=1 and then B=0. If infinity is not fixed, c is nonzero and all three fixed points are finite. Each satisfies \(cz^2+(d-a)z-b=0\), a nonzero quadratic that cannot have three distinct roots. This case is impossible. Thus only identity has the prescribed three fixed points.
