Curvature and Absolute Geometry
Compare three curvature signs, common geometric properties, and the Euclidean behavior of small regions.
Learning goals
- Compare distance and area for negative, zero, and positive curvature.
- Interpret homogeneity, isotropy, and invariant metrics.
- Prove small-scale limits and reason about product geometries.
A shared family of geometries
Euclidean, spherical and hyperbolic geometry answer many of the same questions with different formulas. Curvature organizes those differences, including triangle angle sums and the growth of circles. We will compare equal intrinsic measurements so the comparison reflects geometry rather than drawing scale.
Here “absolute geometry” means concepts and results shared by Euclidean, hyperbolic, and elliptic geometries. Some books use the term more narrowly for neutral geometry, omitting the parallel axiom. Keep this terminology distinction in mind.
Curvature parameter
\[ds=\frac{2|dz|}{1+k|z|^2},\qquad dA=\frac{4\,dx\,dy}{(1+k|z|^2)^2}\]For negative k use the disk where the denominator is positive. For positive k use spherical charts with antipodal identification when studying the single elliptic model. At k zero the metric is twice the ordinary coordinate length.
| Curvature | Model type | Triangle angle sum |
|---|---|---|
| \(k<0\) | Hyperbolic | \(<\pi\) |
| \(k=0\) | Euclidean | \(=\pi\) |
| \(k>0\) | Elliptic / spherical | \(>\pi\) |
Angle excess records curvature
We have seen separate area formulas in the flat, hyperbolic, and spherical settings. Put them beside one another and a common relationship appears. The sign of curvature tells us whether a triangle gains angle, loses angle, or has the Euclidean sum.
\[\alpha+\beta+\gamma-\pi=kA\]This relation applies to the convex geodesic triangles under discussion. A larger region can reveal curvature more clearly, while a small area gives an angle sum close to pi.
Infer the curvature
A triangle has area \(2\) and angle sum \(\pi-0.2\). Find \(k\).
Show worked solution
The negative sign identifies hyperbolic geometry. The numerical value depends on the length unit used.
Rescale a sphere
A sphere has radius three. Determine its curvature and the area of a triangle with excess pi over six.
Show worked solution
Separate a change of scale from a change of shape
If every intrinsic length is multiplied by a positive factor s, areas multiply by \(s^2\) while angles remain unchanged. The triangle relation \(E=\alpha+\beta+\gamma-\pi=kA\) then forces the new curvature to be \(k/s^2\). Curvature has inverse-square-length units; its numerical value depends on scale, but its sign does not.
Compare two models of the same angular triangle
A hyperbolic triangle has curvature \(-1\) and area \(\pi/6\). A scaled copy doubles every intrinsic length. Find its new area, curvature, and angle sum.
Show worked solution
Area becomes \(4(\pi/6)=2\pi/3\) and curvature becomes \(-1/4\). Their product stays \(-\pi/6\), so the angle sum stays \(5\pi/6\). Doubling lengths does not double the angle defect. An isometry preserves lengths within one geometry; this rescaling compares metrics and is not an isometry.
At zero curvature, the equation kA=E reduces to E=0 and cannot recover area from angles. Similar Euclidean triangles can have the same angles but arbitrarily different areas. Division by curvature is valid only when curvature is nonzero.
Radius formulas in all three cases
Comparing radius formulas is easier when we keep the meaning of radius fixed: intrinsic distance from the center. Check the curvature convention and its scale before comparing constants. The flat limit then becomes a consistency check on how the curved formulas connect to familiar Euclidean measurements.
| Geometry | Circle circumference at radius R | Disk area |
|---|---|---|
| Negative curvature −h² | \(2\pi\sinh(hR)/h\) | \(2\pi(\cosh(hR)-1)/h^2\) |
| Zero curvature | \(2\pi R\) | \(\pi R^2\) |
| Positive curvature h² | \(2\pi\sin(hR)/h\) | \(2\pi(1-\cos(hR))/h^2\) |
For positive curvature these are spherical cap formulas with the corresponding radius restrictions. In the single elliptic model use disk radii below the cut locus.
Prove the local area limit
Show \(A/(\pi R^2)\to1\) as \(R\to0\) for each curvature sign.
Show worked solution
For negative curvature rewrite the ratio as \([\sinh(hR/2)/(hR/2)]^2\); for positive curvature use \([\sin(hR/2)/(hR/2)]^2\). Both tend to one. At zero curvature the ratio is identically one.
Prove the local circumference limit
Show \(C/(2\pi R)\to1\).
Show worked solution
The ratios are \(\sinh(hR)/(hR)\), one, and \(\sin(hR)/(hR)\). The first and last tend to one by their derivatives at zero.
Homogeneous, metric, and isotropic
Location, distance and direction are separate issues
A metric assigns a nonnegative real distance to each pair of points, with distance zero if and only if the points coincide, equal distances in either order, and each direct distance no greater than the sum of the distances through a third point.
Homogeneity and isotropy
Homogeneity means allowed transformations can carry any point to any other. Isotropy means allowed transformations fixing a point can carry any tangent direction there to any other.
Neither a distance formula alone nor freedom to change location establishes isotropy.
A geometry can look the same from every point without treating every direction equally. It may also have a group of transformations before we have chosen a distance. Separating these properties helps us avoid importing an assumption from the Euclidean picture.
- Homogeneous: an allowed transformation can move any point to any other point.
- Metric: a distance is nonnegative, vanishes only for equal points, is symmetric, satisfies the triangle inequality, and is preserved by the allowed group.
- Isotropic: at a point, all tangent directions are equivalent under allowed motions fixing that point.
Translations are homogeneous but not isotropic
Explain both statements for the translation group of the plane.
Show worked solution
Translation by the displacement between two points maps the first to the second. But the only translation fixing a point is identity, so it cannot turn one tangent direction into a different direction. Euclidean distance is nevertheless invariant under translations.
The full Möbius group does not preserve an ordinary continuous distance on the sphere. This is a claim about a metric compatible with its topology; the abstract discrete metric is an exception if continuity is not required.
Product geometries
Having separated distance from symmetry properties, we can now build spaces by combining simpler ones. Think about moving in one factor while holding the other coordinate fixed, then about moving in both. The product metric tells us how those contributions combine. It does not follow that all directions have interchangeable geometric roles.
For geometries \((S_1,G_1)\) and \((S_2,G_2)\), the product acts coordinate by coordinate: \((g_1,g_2)(x,y)=(g_1x,g_2y)\). Its group is fixed by this definition; it need not contain every motion of the resulting surface.
Prove homogeneity of a product
Assume both factors are homogeneous. Prove their product is homogeneous.
Show worked solution
For any starting and target pair, choose in each factor a transformation taking its starting coordinate to its target coordinate. The pair of transformations lies in the product group and carries the entire starting pair to the target pair.
Construct an invariant product metric
If \(d_1,d_2\) are invariant metrics, prove \(d((x,y),(u,v))=d_1(x,u)+d_2(y,v)\) is one too.
Show worked solution
Both terms are nonnegative and their sum vanishes exactly when both coordinate pairs agree. Symmetry follows term by term. Add the two factor triangle inequalities to obtain the product triangle inequality. Applying a product transformation leaves each term unchanged, establishing invariance.
A flat torus is not a doughnut metric
The shape used to draw a space does not automatically determine its intrinsic measurements. A flat torus and an ordinary doughnut surface share a topological description, but their distances and curvature differ. Ask which metric is being used before trusting the appearance.
A product of two circles with a product metric is homogeneous: independent circle rotations move any point to any other. A torus drawn as a doughnut in ordinary three-dimensional space has a different induced surface metric, with varying curvature. Topological resemblance does not make these metric geometries identical.
Practice: product of two translation lines
Identify the group of the product of two one-dimensional translation geometries.
Show worked solution
This is the plane’s translation geometry. It is homogeneous and admits invariant metrics, but the specified group has no rotations about a point and is not isotropic.
Absolute Geometry: discussion A–D
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Question A
Verify that \(A_1\) and \(A_{-1}\) recover the elliptic and hyperbolic formulas.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Setting \(k=1\) gives matrices with \(|a|^2+|b|^2=1\), antipodal relation \(z_1\bar z_2=-1\), line element \(2|dz|/(1+|z|^2)\) and its spherical area element. Setting \(k=-1\) gives \(|a|^2-|b|^2=1\), reflection relation \(z_1\bar z_2=1\), and line element \(2|dz|/(1-|z|^2)\) on the open unit disk. The ideal boundary is excluded from the hyperbolic space; including it would make the metric singular.
Question B
Check that \(A_0\) is Euclidean geometry and identify its straight lines.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
For \(k=0\), \(|a|=1\) and \(T(z)=(az+b)/\bar a=a^2z+ab\), exactly rotations followed by translations. The limiting geodesic condition says the cline passes through infinity, so the geodesics are Euclidean lines. The line element is \(2|dz|\) and the area element \(4\,dx\,dy\), so coordinates have a constant factor of two in length relative to ordinary Euclidean coordinates. Infinity is not a finite-distance point of this plane.
Question C
Check that a product of transformation groups acts as a transformation group.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
On \(S_1\times S_2\), \((T_1,T_2)\) acts by \((x,y)\mapsto(T_1x,T_2y)\). Each such map is a bijection, with inverse \((T_1^{-1},T_2^{-1})\). The identity is \((I_1,I_2)\), and composition is componentwise: \((T_1,T_2)(U_1,U_2)=(T_1U_1,T_2U_2)\). Associativity follows in each coordinate.
Question D
If the two component geometries have dimensions \(k\) and \(h\), what is the dimension of their product?
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
For manifold models, local coordinates from the first factor and the second factor combine independently, producing \(k+h\) coordinates. Thus the product has dimension \(k+h\). This uses the manifold meaning of dimension, not a claim for arbitrary sets without a dimension theory.
Absolute Geometry: exercises 1–6
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 1
Verify the transformations of \(A_k\) form a group and preserve the identification \(kz_1\bar z_2+1=0\).
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Use \(M(a,b)=\begin{pmatrix}a&b\\-k\bar b&\bar a\end{pmatrix}\) with \(|a|^2+k|b|^2=1\). Multiplication gives the same form with \(A=ac-kb\bar d\) and \(B=ad+b\bar c\); determinant multiplicativity gives \(|A|^2+k|B|^2=1\). The inverse is \(M(\bar a,-b)\), and \(M(1,0)\) is the identity.
For finite nonpole points, direct expansion gives \[1+kT(z_1)\overline{T(z_2)}=\frac{1+kz_1\bar z_2}{(-k\bar bz_1+\bar a)(-kb\bar z_2+a)}.\] Thus the identification is preserved; limits handle poles. For \(k<0\), the identity \[1+k|Tz|^2=\frac{1+k|z|^2}{|-k\bar bz+\bar a|^2}\] also shows preservation of the metric disk. Here the group is \(G_k\); \(A_k\) denotes the geometry, not literally the group.
Exercise 2
For \(k\ne0\), analyze the moduli of an identified pair and derive a disk model.
Corrects the radius and excludes the ideal boundary for negative curvature.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
The relation gives \(|z_1||z_2|=1/|k|=R^2\), where \(R=1/\sqrt{|k|}\). If one modulus is less than \(R\), the other is greater; if one equals \(R\), so does the other. For \(k>0\) the boundary representatives are antipodal, and the closed disk with opposite boundary points identified is the single elliptic model.
For \(k<0\) a boundary point is paired with itself, but the length density is singular there. Exclude the boundary and choose the inside representative from each inside/outside pair to get the open disk model. The scan's displayed \(R=\sqrt{|k|}\) is inconsistent with its identification equation; the reciprocal square root is required.
Exercise 3
For \(k>0\), prove there are no parallel lines and triangle angle sums exceed \(\pi\).
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Set \(w=\sqrt{k}\,z\). This sends the representative disk to the unit disk and the identification to antipodal identification. Its geodesics become great circles, so any two projective lines meet. Lengths are \(1/\sqrt{k}\) times unit-model lengths, and areas \(1/k\) times unit-model areas. Angles are unchanged. Hence the unit elliptic relation gives \(\alpha+\beta+\gamma=\pi+kA>\pi\) for a nondegenerate triangle.
Exercise 4
For \(k<0\), describe the geodesics and prove the triangle angle sum is less than \(\pi\).
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Write \(\kappa=\sqrt{-k}\) and \(w=\kappa z\). The identification becomes reflection in the unit circle; geodesics become diameters and circle arcs orthogonal to it. In original coordinates they are diameters and clines orthogonal to \(|z|=1/\kappa\). The metric disk is open. Area scales by \(1/\kappa^2\), so the unit hyperbolic defect formula gives \(\pi-(\alpha+\beta+\gamma)=\kappa^2A=-kA>0\).
Exercise 5
Prove \(kA=\alpha+\beta+\gamma-\pi\) in all three curvature cases. What happens at \(k=0\)?
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
For \(k>0\), rescale coordinates by \(\sqrt{k}\) to the unit sphere model. This preserves angles and multiplies areas by \(k\), so its angular-excess theorem gives the result. For \(k<0\), rescale by \(\sqrt{-k}\); the unit hyperbolic formula gives \((-k)A=\pi-\sum\alpha\), equivalent to the same equation. For \(k=0\), Euclidean triangle angles sum to \(\pi\), so both sides are zero. This case says nothing about Euclidean area; division by \(k\) would be invalid.
Exercise 6
In curvature \(k\), find (a) distance, (b) disk area from radius \(R\), and (c) circumference from radius \(R\).
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Put \(q=|(z_2-z_1)/(1+k\bar z_1z_2)|\). For \(k<0\), writing \(\kappa=\sqrt{-k}\) gives \[d=\frac{2}{\kappa}\operatorname{artanh}(\kappa q),\quad A=\frac{2\pi}{\kappa^2}(\cosh(\kappa R)-1),\quad C=\frac{2\pi}{\kappa}\sinh(\kappa R).\] For \(k=0\), \(d=2|z_2-z_1|\), \(A=\pi R^2\), and \(C=2\pi R\).
For \(k>0\), writing \(\kappa=\sqrt{k}\) gives spherical distance \(D=2\arctan(\kappa q)/\kappa\) and projective distance \(d=\min(D,\pi/\kappa-D)\). Also \[A=\frac{2\pi}{k}(1-\cos(\kappa R)),\qquad C=\frac{2\pi}{\kappa}\sin(\kappa R).\] The projective circumference formula assumes \(0<R<\pi/(2\kappa)\); at the endpoint the boundary line has half the limiting length. Spherical cap formulas use \(0\le R\le\pi/\kappa\) without that boundary identification.
Derivation: move the center to zero and integrate \(2\,dr/(1+kr^2)\) for radius, \(4r\,dr\,d\theta/(1+kr^2)^2\) for area, and \(2r\,d\theta/(1+kr^2)\) for circumference; substitute the radius relation in each case.
Absolute Geometry: exercises 7–12
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 7
Classify the conic \(x^2+ky^2=1\) for each sign of \(k\).
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
For \(k>0\) it is an ellipse, with semiaxes \(1\) and \(1/\sqrt{k}\) (a circle when \(k=1\)). For \(k<0\) it is a hyperbola opening along the \(x\)-axis. For \(k=0\) it is the pair of parallel lines \(x=\pm1\), a degenerate conic; it is not an ordinary parabola. The source calls this a degenerate parabola, referring to its degenerate parabolic conic type.
Exercise 8
Prove side-angle-side congruence in the three constant-curvature geometries.
Explicitly handles orientation and short-arc hypotheses rather than silently adding a reflection to the holomorphic group.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Move the first triangle's included vertex to the second's, then rotate its first side ray onto the corresponding ray. If the oriented included angles agree, the second side ray also coincides. On each chosen ray the point at a specified distance is unique, provided spherical sides are minor arcs and avoid the antipodal ambiguity. The two equal side lengths therefore place both remaining vertices at the corresponding points, so the triangles coincide.
If the triangles have opposite orientation, first reflect one before aligning. Thus the usual unoriented SAS statement uses the full isometry group, including reflections. With the book's orientation-preserving Möbius subgroup alone, the corresponding oriented-angle condition is necessary.
Exercise 9
Prove the longest side lies opposite the largest angle in a nondegenerate convex triangle.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Euclidean case: the cosine rule, or its standard side-angle comparison proof, gives \(a>b\) exactly when \(A>B\).
Hyperbolic case, in unit-curvature lengths: subtracting the two cosine-law expressions yields \[\cos A-\cos B=\frac{\sinh(a-b)[\cosh c-\cosh(a+b)]}{\sinh a\sinh b\sinh c}.\] The denominator is positive and \(c<a+b\), so the bracket is negative. Since cosine decreases on \((0,\pi)\), \(A-B\) has the sign of \(a-b\).
Spherical case: for minor sides of a convex spherical triangle, subtraction similarly gives \[\cos A-\cos B=\frac{\sin(a-b)[\cos(a+b)-\cos c]}{\sin a\sin b\sin c}.\] Here \(0<a,b,c<\pi\) and \(|a-b|<c<\min(a+b,2\pi-a-b)\). The bracket is negative, while \(\sin(a-b)\) has the sign of \(a-b\). Thus the same conclusion holds. Rescaling proves other nonzero curvatures. A projective triangle must be interpreted through a consistent convex spherical lift; arbitrary long arcs are not covered.
Exercise 10
Prove each side length of a nondegenerate triangle is strictly less than the sum of the other two.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
The broken path along two sides connects the endpoints of the third. A shortest geodesic has no greater length. Equality can occur only when the broken path itself is a minimizing geodesic with no corner: at the middle vertex, noncollinear tangent directions can be rounded locally to shorten the path. A nondegenerate triangle has a genuine corner, so the inequality is strict. This applies in the Euclidean and hyperbolic planes and to shortest arcs in the spherical/projective models.
Exercise 11
Prove that the area of a small radius-\(r\) disk satisfies \(A/(\pi r^2)\to1\).
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
For \(k>0\), \(A=4\pi\sin^2(\sqrt{k}r/2)/k\), so the ratio is \([\sin u/u]^2\) with \(u=\sqrt{k}r/2\), which tends to one. For \(k<0\), replace sine by hyperbolic sine, and \(\sinh u/u\to1\). For \(k=0\) the ratio is identically one. More precisely \(A=\pi r^2-k\pi r^4/12+O(r^6)\).
Exercise 12
Prove that the circumference of a small radius-\(r\) circle satisfies \(C/(2\pi r)\to1\).
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
For \(k>0\), the ratio is \(\sin(\sqrt{k}r)/(\sqrt{k}r)\); for \(k<0\), it is \(\sinh(\sqrt{-k}r)/(\sqrt{-k}r)\); for \(k=0\), it equals one. Each tends to one. The expansion is \(C=2\pi r-k\pi r^3/3+O(r^5)\).
Absolute Geometry: exercises 13–18
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 13
Prove a product of homogeneous geometries is homogeneous.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Given \((a,b)\) and \((c,d)\), homogeneity supplies \(T_1\) with \(T_1a=c\) and \(T_2\) with \(T_2b=d\). Their product transformation sends \((a,b)\) to \((c,d)\). Hence the product action is transitive.
Exercise 14
Prove a product of metric geometries admits an invariant metric.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
If the factor metrics are \(d_1,d_2\), define \[d((a,b),(c,e))=d_1(a,c)+d_2(b,e).\] It is nonnegative, vanishes exactly when both coordinates agree, and is symmetric. Adding the two factor triangle inequalities gives the product triangle inequality. Componentwise transformations preserve each summand, so the metric is invariant. Other choices, such as \(\sqrt{d_1^2+d_2^2}\), are possible; a product action alone does not select a unique metric.
Exercise 15
Verify the one-dimensional Euclidean and elliptic models are geometries.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
On \(\mathbb R\), translations \(T_ax=x+a\) are bijections, \(T_aT_b=T_{a+b}\), \(T_0=I\), and \(T_a^{-1}=T_{-a}\). On the unit circle, rotations \(R_\theta z=e^{i\theta}z\) are bijections, \(R_\theta R_\phi=R_{\theta+\phi}\), \(R_0=I\), and \(R_\theta^{-1}=R_{-\theta}\). Each therefore supplies a transformation group on its stated set.
Exercise 16
Analyze \(E^1\times E^1\): is it homogeneous, metric, isotropic, and what geometry is it?
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Its set is \(\mathbb R^2\) and its transformations are \((x,y)\mapsto(x+a,y+b)\), so it is the translation geometry introduced earlier. It is homogeneous and admits the Euclidean metric or the sum metric \(|\Delta x|+|\Delta y|\). It is not isotropic under this specified group: the only translation fixing a point is the identity, so there are no nontrivial rotations about that point. Having a Euclidean metric does not automatically enlarge the given transformation group.
Exercise 17
Analyze \(E^1\times S^1\) and describe its cylinder model.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Represent a point by \((x,e^{i\theta})\) and embed it as \((\cos\theta,\sin\theta,x)\) on the infinite unit cylinder. Product transformations are axial translations and rotations around the axis. They are transitive, so the geometry is homogeneous. An invariant metric is \(|x-y|+\delta(\theta,\phi)\), where \(\delta\) is the shorter circular angle; the usual flat-cylinder product metric is another choice. It is not isotropic under the product group, since a transformation fixing a point must be the identity.
Exercise 18
Choose straight lines on \(E^1\times S^1\), discuss Euclid's postulates, and determine triangle angle sums.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
Choose the flat Riemannian product metric and unroll the cylinder to the plane. Projections of ordinary lines are its geodesics: axial lines, horizontal closed circles and helices. Two cylinder points admit connecting geodesics with different winding numbers, so the first postulate's uniqueness fails globally. Geodesics extend indefinitely (some close), and right angles are locally congruent. Arbitrarily large metric circles are not ordinary Euclidean circles after wrapping, so the global circle postulate also needs qualification.
A simple contractible geodesic triangle bounding a disk lifts to a Euclidean triangle and has angle sum \(\pi\). Three arbitrary wrapped arcs may not bound a triangular disk at all, so no unconditional triangle-angle assertion should be made for them. The sum metric from the earlier exercise has different geodesics and no canonical Euclidean angle notion; specifying the metric is necessary.
Absolute Geometry: exercises 19
Work through each question before revealing its solution. For proof questions, compare both the reasoning and the required hypotheses.
Exercise 19
Analyze \(S^1\times S^1\) and compare it with the doughnut-shaped torus.
Show worked solution
Approach. Normalize the figure using an isometry, then apply the definition.
The product consists of two independent angles modulo \(2\pi\). Angle translations act transitively, so it is homogeneous. The sum of the two circular distances is an invariant metric; the flat Riemannian product metric is also invariant. The specified product group is not isotropic because its point stabilizers contain only the identity.
Topologically this is a torus, just like a doughnut surface. Geometrically its flat product metric has zero curvature everywhere. The usual torus embedded in three-dimensional Euclidean space has positive curvature outside, negative curvature inside, and zero curvature along its top and bottom circles. That induced metric is not the flat product metric and is not homogeneous. A drawing of a torus therefore does not determine its intrinsic geometry.
References and further study
Primary source: Michael Henle, Modern Geometries: Non-Euclidean, Projective, and Discrete, 2nd edition, Prentice Hall, 2001, pp. 125–132. ISBN 9780130323132. The supplied chapter scans determine the discussion sequence and source questions. Solutions are worked explanations; qualifications are noted where needed.
Book bibliographic record. Supplementary course notes provide supporting examples and model conventions.
Continue exploring
Synthesis and proof challenges
The sign of curvature is a geometric distinction, whereas its numerical magnitude depends on the unit of length. Product geometries also show why preserving a distance does not automatically give every familiar Euclidean symmetry.
Reasoning · Change the length unit
A geodesic triangle has angle excess \(-0.3\) radians and area \(6\) square units. Find the curvature. If every measured length is multiplied by 10 because of a new unit, find the new area and curvature and verify the excess remains unchanged.
Hint
Use excess=kA; area scales as the square of the length factor.
Show worked solution
Initially \(k=-0.3/6=-0.05\). The new numerical area is \(100\cdot6=600\), so the new curvature is \(-0.3/600=-0.0005\). The product remains \(-0.0005\cdot600=-0.3\). The sign is unchanged, but curvature's numerical value is divided by the square of the scale factor.
Advanced / Honors · A distance without rotational invariance
For plane points define \(d((x,y),(u,v))=|x-u|+|y-v|\). Show that it is invariant under translations, but not under all rotations. Describe its unit circle about the origin.
Hint
Translations cancel in differences. Compare a unit horizontal vector with its forty-five-degree rotation.
Show worked solution
Adding the same (a,b) to both points leaves both coordinate differences unchanged, proving translation invariance. The distance from (0,0) to (1,0) is 1; rotating by \(\pi/4\) sends the second point to \((1/\sqrt2,1/\sqrt2)\), whose distance is \(\sqrt2\). Thus that rotation is not an isometry for this metric. The unit circle is \(|x|+|y|=1\), a diamond with vertices (1,0),(0,1),(-1,0),(0,-1). The word circle means a distance locus relative to the chosen metric.
